The Adequacy of the Moral Argument for Explaining the...

The Adequacy of the Moral Argument for Explaining the Existence of God The moral argument like many arguments for the existence of God comes in many different forms. All of these set out to prove God’s existence from the evidence of morality in the world. Morality is about understanding the difference between the right and wrong action in a situation, the moral person has this understanding and then acts appropriately. The moral arguments first problem or flaw is that it assumes and works on the principle that the majority of people have some experience of morality. Newman presumes God’s existence not from moral law but from the fact of conscience ‘we fell responsibility†¦the voice of†¦show more content†¦He argued that there were certain, rationally discoverable laws which we are duty bound as a religious experience which points towards God. Every time we make a moral decision, we choose between possible courses of action. A sense of obligation guides us to make this choice. Trethowan traces this obligation to the fact that each person has value A sense of value thus underpins each moral decision. If we accept that people have intrinsic value, then there must be a source to this value, he takes this to be God; ‘we have value because we receive it from a source of value. That is what I mean, for a start, by God. That is why the demand upon us to develop ourselves is an absolute, unconditional demand.’[3] Critics say that Kant presupposes too much, and that his faith in the summum bonnum is misplaced. They argue that any belief that there is more to life then what we see can be explained as a projection of our human powers on to an imaginary God as Ludwig Feuerbach held. Or wishful thinking that creates the imaginary comfort of a heavenly father who can forgive our wrong doing, as Sigmund Freud believed. These also seem to suggest that the moral argument is not adequateShow MoreRelatedMaking Sence of Homonegativity10662 Words   |  43 Pageseffeminate. Participants also drew upon their religious beliefs, internal affective reactions, and beliefs that homosexuality is unnatural and a choice in order to make sense of their homonegativity. The suitability of various theoretical frameworks for explaining participants’ homonegativity is discussed. Keywords: discrimination; gay; homosexuality; Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis; lesbian; prejudice; qualitative Relatively little is known about the ways in which heterosexual men and women whoRead MoreDeveloping Effective Research Proposals49428 Words   |  198 Pagesthe view that neither approach is better than the other, that both are needed, that both have their strengths and weaknesses, and that they can and should be combined as appropriate. Rather than either–or thinking about this distinction, or tired arguments about the superiority of one approach over the other, the viewpoint here is that the methods and data used (quantitative, qualitative or both) should follow from, and fit in with, the question(s) being asked. In particular, quantitative questionsRead MoreOrganisational Theory230255 Words   |  922 Pageschapters as a starting point for getting to grips with the field of organization theory. Dr Martin Brigham, Lancaster University, UK McAuley et al. provide a highly readable account of ideas, perspectives and practices of organization. By thoroughly explaining, analyz ing and exploring organization theory the book increases the understanding of a field that in recent years has become ever more fragmented. Organization theory is central to managing, organizing and reflecting on both formal and informalRead MoreLibrary Management204752 Words   |  820 Pagesdevelopments that have really been taken from the past? Jonathan Shaw, â€Å"Who Built the Pyramids?† Harvard Magazine, July–August 2003, 42–49, 99. Although the records of early Greece offer little insight into the principles of management, the very existence of the Athenian commonwealth, with its councils, popular courts, administrative officials, and board of generals, indicates an appreciation of various managerial functions. Socrates’ definition of management as a skill separate from technical knowledgeRead MoreBhopal Gas Disaster84210 Words   |  337 Pagessuffering from physical disorders. My first son fell ill when he was eight years old. My second son was born dead and with a half-formed skull. All the kids in our family are physically retarded,† said Shahida, a resident of Blue Moon colony in Bhopal. Explaining that they are forced to use the contaminated tubewell water because of scarcity of water, the children in the area are developing s kin diseases. Gas victims allege bungling of funds Pioneer News Service / New Delhi The plea by Bhopal Gas tragedyRead MoreProject Managment Case Studies214937 Words   |  860 PagesComponents Division. QUESTIONS 1. What are some of the major problems facing the management of Hyten in accepting formalized project management? (Include attitude problems/personality problems.) 2. Do any of the managers appear to have valid arguments for their beliefs as to why formal project management should not be considered? 34 HYTEN CORPORATION 3. Are there any good reasons why Hyten should go to formal project management? 4. Has Hyten taken a reasonable approach toward implementingRead MoreMarketing Management 14th Edition Test Bank Kotler Test Bank173911 Words   |  696 Pagesorganizations often charge a premium over their normal prices because these organizations are largely indifferent to price. Answer: FALSE Page Ref: 9 Objective: 2 AACSB: Reflective thinking Difficulty: Easy 90) Shops and stores have a physical existence and as such are examples of marketspace. Answer: FALSE Page Ref: 9 Objective: 2 AACSB: Use of IT Difficulty: Easy 91) Wants are basic human requirements, such as food and shelter. Answer: FALSE Page Ref: 9-10 Objective: 3 Difficulty: